Google Pixel 8 vs Google Pixel 9 Pro XL

Google Pixel 8
Google Pixel 8
Starting at

Refurbished price:A$465.00

Versus A$1,245.00 new

See options
Google Pixel 9 Pro XL
Google Pixel 9 Pro XL
Starting at

Refurbished price:A$853.00

Versus A$1,849.00 new

See options

Ratings

The Google Pixel 8, released in October 2023, and the Google Pixel 9 Pro XL, launched in August 2024, represent different generations within Google's flagship smartphone lineup. While both devices offer a pure Android experience and a strong focus on computational photography, the Pixel 9 Pro XL introduces advancements in processing power, display technology, and camera capabilities, alongside a larger form factor. Both operate on the Android platform, benefiting from Google's consistent software updates and feature enhancements.

Scores

Durability

When considering the longevity of these devices, both the Pixel 8 and Pixel 9 Pro XL offer substantial software support, a key factor for long-term usability.

  • Release Timeline: The Pixel 8 was released in October 2023, while the Pixel 9 Pro XL followed in August 2024. This means the Pixel 9 Pro XL benefits from a later starting point in its support cycle.
  • Software Longevity: Both models are part of Google's commitment to providing seven years of OS and security updates. The Pixel 8 is supported until at least October 2030, and the Pixel 9 Pro XL is supported until at least August 2031, offering an extended period of up-to-date software and security features.
  • Physical Durability: Both devices feature an IP68 rating for dust and water resistance, indicating a high level of protection against environmental elements. The Pixel 8 utilizes Gorilla Glass Victus 2 on its front and Gorilla Glass Victus on its back for scratch and drop resistance. The Pixel 9 Pro XL is also built with durable materials, likely featuring an updated generation of protective glass, contributing to its overall robust construction.

Release year

2023

2024

Compatible with latest Update

Yes

Yes

Operating system

Android

Android

Foldable

No

No

Performance

The performance of a smartphone is central to the user experience, influencing everything from app responsiveness to demanding tasks like gaming and advanced photo editing.

  • Processing Power: The Pixel 8 is powered by the Google Tensor G3, which provides solid performance for daily applications and general multitasking. The Pixel 9 Pro XL, featuring the newer Google Tensor G4, offers enhanced processing capabilities, resulting in smoother operation and more efficient handling of complex tasks and AI-driven features.
  • Multitasking and Storage: The Pixel 8 comes with 8GB of RAM, which is sufficient for most users' multitasking needs. The Pixel 9 Pro XL elevates this with 16GB of RAM, allowing for more seamless switching between numerous applications and improved performance in memory-intensive scenarios. Both devices offer storage options starting at 128GB, with the Pixel 9 Pro XL extending to larger capacities up to 1TB, catering to users with extensive storage requirements.
  • Battery Behavior: The Pixel 8 includes a 4575 mAh battery, generally providing a full day of use for moderate users, though heavy usage, particularly with 5G, may necessitate more frequent charging. The Pixel 9 Pro XL features a larger 5060 mAh battery, which, combined with its more efficient processor, often translates to extended battery life, with some users reporting multi-day usage under typical conditions. Both support fast wired and wireless charging.

Memory (GB)

8 GB

16 GB

Screen quality

The display is a primary interface for smartphone interaction, and both Pixel models offer high-quality viewing experiences with distinct characteristics.

  • Display Technology and Resolution: The Pixel 8 features a 6.2-inch Actua OLED display with a Full HD+ resolution (1080 x 2400 pixels), providing clear and vibrant visuals for everyday content. The Pixel 9 Pro XL boasts a larger 6.8-inch LTPO OLED display with a Quad HD+ resolution (1344 x 2992 pixels), offering a sharper and more expansive viewing area, particularly beneficial for detailed content and immersive media consumption.
  • Brightness and Refresh Rate: Both phones feature a 120Hz refresh rate, ensuring smooth scrolling and fluid animations. The Pixel 8's display can reach a peak brightness of up to 2000 nits, making it visible in bright outdoor conditions. The Pixel 9 Pro XL further enhances this with a peak brightness of up to 3000 nits, providing superior visibility and HDR content reproduction even in direct sunlight.
  • Viewing Experience: The Pixel 8's more compact screen size makes it easier for one-handed use and pocketability. The Pixel 9 Pro XL's larger display is well-suited for users who prioritize a more immersive experience for gaming, video streaming, and productivity tasks, though its size may impact handling for some.

Resolution

1080 x 2400

1344 x 2992

Screen type

OLED

LTPO OLED

Audiovisual

Google Pixel phones are renowned for their camera capabilities, and both the Pixel 8 and Pixel 9 Pro XL continue this tradition with advanced imaging systems.

  • Rear Camera System: The Pixel 8 features a dual-camera setup with a 50 MP main sensor and a 12 MP ultrawide lens, delivering impressive photo quality, especially in low-light conditions. The Pixel 9 Pro XL steps up with a triple-camera system, including a 50 MP main sensor, a 48 MP ultrawide lens, and a 48 MP telephoto lens with 5x optical zoom, offering greater versatility for various photographic scenarios, including distant subjects.
  • Photography Features: Both devices leverage Google's computational photography for features like Night Sight and Super Res Zoom, enhancing image quality across different lighting and zoom levels. The Pixel 9 Pro XL's dedicated telephoto lens provides superior optical zoom capabilities compared to the Pixel 8's digital zoom. User reviews often praise the Pixel's color accuracy and dynamic range.
  • Video and Front Camera: The Pixel 8 supports 4K video recording at up to 60fps. The Pixel 9 Pro XL further enhances video capabilities, including 8K video recording and improved stabilization. For selfies, the Pixel 8 has a 10.5 MP front camera with fixed focus, while the Pixel 9 Pro XL features a higher-resolution 42 MP front camera with autofocus, leading to sharper and more detailed self-portraits.

Main camera

50 megapixels

50 megapixels

Front camera

10.5 megapixels

42 megapixels

Miscellaneous

Beyond core specifications, several practical elements contribute to the overall user experience and differentiate these two Pixel smartphones.

  • Connectivity and Ports: Both devices support modern connectivity standards, including 5G and Wi-Fi 7, ensuring fast and reliable wireless communication. They both feature a USB-C port for charging and data transfer. The Pixel 9 Pro XL is expected to support Bluetooth 5.4, a slight upgrade from the Pixel 8's Bluetooth 5.3, potentially offering minor improvements in wireless accessory connectivity.
  • Biometric Security: Both the Pixel 8 and Pixel 9 Pro XL incorporate under-display fingerprint sensors and face recognition for secure unlocking and authentication. The Pixel 9 Pro XL may feature an ultrasonic fingerprint sensor for potentially faster and more reliable recognition compared to the Pixel 8's optical sensor.
  • Design and Handling: The Pixel 8 is designed to be a more compact device, weighing 187 grams and measuring 150.5 x 70.8 x 8.9 mm, making it comfortable for one-handed use. The Pixel 9 Pro XL, with its 6.8-inch display, is a larger device, offering a more expansive screen but also a greater physical presence. Its dimensions are approximately 162.8 x 76.6 x 8.5 mm. The Pixel 9 Pro XL features a more refined and premium build, with a sleek design and a distinctive camera bar.

Weight

187 oz

221 oz

Screen size (in)

6.2

6.8

Network

5G

5G

SIM card

Physical SIM + eSIM

Physical SIM + eSIM

Carrier compatibility

Unlocked

Unlocked

The Google Pixel 8 and Pixel 9 Pro XL cater to slightly different user preferences, each excelling in various aspects based on their respective release timelines and design philosophies.

Users of the Pixel 8 frequently praise its impressive camera system, which consistently delivers high-quality photos, particularly in challenging lighting conditions. Its compact design and clean Android experience are also commonly highlighted as significant advantages. However, some users have noted that the battery life, while improved over previous generations, can still be a concern with heavy usage, especially when utilizing 5G connectivity. The charging speed is also sometimes mentioned as being slower compared to some competitors.

The Pixel 9 Pro XL, being a newer and larger model, receives commendation for its vibrant and expansive display, offering superior brightness and resolution. Its advanced camera system, including a dedicated telephoto lens and enhanced video capabilities, is a major draw, with users appreciating the versatility and quality of images and videos. The device's robust performance, thanks to its newer processor and increased RAM, ensures smooth operation across all tasks. Many users also report excellent, often multi-day, battery life. Some common feedback points include its larger physical size, which might not appeal to all users, and occasional observations regarding specific camera processing characteristics like skin tone rendering.

Users prioritizing a more compact form factor, a highly capable camera for everyday photography, and a slightly more accessible device may find the Pixel 8 well-suited to their needs. Conversely, users who value a larger, more immersive display, the most advanced camera system with optical zoom, and top-tier performance for demanding applications will likely lean towards the Pixel 9 Pro XL. Both devices offer a pure Android experience and long-term software support, making them reliable choices for extended use. For those seeking an eco-friendly alternative, quality-assured refurbished options for both models can provide a sustainable choice without compromising on performance or features.

See all articles

Our recent comparisons