Compare models

Galaxy S23+ vs Google Pixel 10 Pro XL

  • 1-year warranty
  • Free standard shipping
  • Free 30-day returns
Galaxy S23+
Starting at

Refurbished price:A$439.00

Versus A$1,752.00 new

See options
Google Pixel 10 Pro XL
Starting at

Refurbished price:A$1,150.00

Versus A$1,434.00 new

See options

Differences at a glance

The Samsung Galaxy S23+ (2023) and the Google Pixel 10 Pro XL (2025) represent large-format flagship Android smartphones launched across different generations. While both models offer expansive screen real estate and premium builds, they differ fundamentally in their release years, software ecosystems, and internal components. Choosing between them involves weighing Samsung's streamlined hardware approach against Google's deep software integration and updated processing capabilities.

Available Models

Colour

Storage

Scores

Durability

When examining hardware longevity and maintenance, these two devices reflect their respective release timelines while providing robust multi-year support structures.

  • Release timeline and software support: The Galaxy S23+ launched in early 2023, whereas the Pixel 10 Pro XL arrived in late 2025, giving the Google model a newer starting point for long-term operating system updates and security patches.
  • Repairability and physical durability: Both handsets incorporate robust aluminum frames and hardened glass protection sheets alongside official water resistance ratings, though standard repair service availability remains steady for both through authorized channels.
  • Expected lifespan: Users can anticipate several more years of active software updates from the Pixel 10 Pro XL due to its recent release, while the Galaxy S23+ relies on its established track record of stability for daily tasks.

Release year

2023

2025

Operating system

Android

Android

Foldable

No

No

Performance

Daily speed and multitasking capabilities differ based on internal hardware generations, though both handle typical workloads without friction.

  • Storage and memory configurations: The Galaxy S23+ typically pairs high-speed storage options with generous memory, whereas the Pixel 10 Pro XL equips a larger baseline memory allocation to facilitate complex background tasks and on-device processing.
  • Everyday responsiveness and gaming: Both devices load heavy applications quickly and transition smoothly between active programs, though newer processing architecture in the Pixel 10 Pro XL offers slight advantages during extended, demanding gaming sessions.
  • Battery behavior: The Pixel 10 Pro XL features a higher-capacity battery cell designed to support its larger display framework, while the Galaxy S23+ manages power efficiency effectively through optimized hardware integration during standard daily usage.

Screen quality

Viewing experiences on both devices emphasize sharp resolution and fluid motion handling, tailored for media consumption and bright daylight legibility.

  • Display technology: Both smartphones utilize advanced organic light-emitting diode panels that deliver deep contrast levels, rich colors, and wide viewing angles suitable for streaming video or reading text.
  • Refresh rate and brightness: Each model supports dynamic refresh rates scaling up to high frequencies for smooth scrolling, alongside high peak brightness outputs that maintain clear visibility under direct sunlight.
  • Screen dimensions: The Pixel 10 Pro XL provides a slightly larger physical workspace, while the Galaxy S23+ maintains a marginally more compact footprint within the large-screen category.

Resolution

1080 x 2340

1344x2992

Audiovisual

Imaging hardware and audio output configurations cater well to multimedia enthusiasts and casual creators alike.

  • Camera system versatility: Both phones incorporate multi-lens rear arrays featuring primary wide lenses with optical image stabilization alongside dedicated ultra-wide options, with the Pixel model adding an expansive telephoto zoom reach.
  • Low-light and video performance: Computational photography processing on both devices brightens dark scenes effectively, while video capture remains stable and detailed across various resolutions.
  • Audio and media output: Stereo speaker setups on both units deliver clear voice separation and balanced sound output for hands-free calls and casual video viewing.

Miscellaneous

Practical physical traits and connectivity standards shape how each device fits into everyday routines.

  • Connectivity and ports: Both models support modern fifth-generation cellular networks, rapid wireless pairing standards, and reversible USB Type-C ports for charging and data transfer.
  • Security sensors: Fast and reliable biometric authentication is handled via under-display fingerprint sensors and secure facial recognition features on both handsets.
  • Physical dimensions and handling: The Galaxy S23+ is slightly lighter and narrower, making it marginally easier to handle with one hand compared to the broader frame of the Pixel 10 Pro XL.

Weight

196 oz

232 oz

Screen size (in)

6.6

6.8

Network

5G

5G

SIM card

Physical SIM + eSIM

Physical SIM + eSIM

Carrier compatibility

Unlocked

Unlocked

What the community thinks

Community discussions on platforms like Reddit frequently highlight the Galaxy S23+ for its dependable thermal management, ergonomic balance, and consistent software performance over time. At the same time, users often praise the Pixel 10 Pro XL for its advanced photo-editing features, expanded memory capacity, and long-term update runway. Common criticisms for the older Samsung model center on its advancing age regarding software support, while some users note that the Google alternative feels heavier in the hand.

Users prioritizing a lighter physical build and proven long-term hardware reliability may prefer the Galaxy S23+, while users seeking extended software support timelines and enhanced photography tools will lean toward the Pixel 10 Pro XL. For buyers exploring sustainable purchasing alternatives, a quality-assured refurbished option from Back Market provides a reliable way to access either of these flagship devices while reducing electronic waste.

Our recent comparisons