iPad 5 (2017, A9 series) vs iPad 8 (2020, A12 series)

iPad 5 (2017, A9 series)
iPad 5 (2017, A9 series)
Starting at

Refurbished price:A$144.00

Versus A$559.00 new

See options
iPad 8 (2020, A12 series)
iPad 8 (2020, A12 series)
Starting at

Refurbished price:A$231.00

Versus A$409.00 new

See options

Ratings

The iPad 2017, also known as the 5th generation iPad, and the iPad 2020, or 8th generation iPad, are both standard tablet models from Apple. Released in March 2017 and September 2020, respectively, these devices offer a foundational iPad experience. While they share the same operating system, iPadOS, the 2020 model introduces a more capable processor and expanded accessory support, setting it apart from its predecessor.

Scores

Durability

The longevity of a tablet is often determined by its release date and the duration of software support it receives. The iPad 2017 and iPad 2020, being released three years apart, have different expectations for their practical lifespan.

  • Release Timeline: The iPad 2017 (5th generation) was introduced in March 2017, while the iPad 2020 (8th generation) followed in September 2020. This three-year difference in release directly impacts their remaining support cycles.
  • OS Support Duration: The iPad 2017 launched with iOS 10.3.2 and received major iPadOS updates up to iPadOS 16.7.15. It is unlikely to receive iPadOS 17, with security updates potentially ceasing in late 2025 or 2026. In contrast, the iPad 2020, starting with iPadOS 14, is currently supported up to iPadOS 17.2 and is expected to continue receiving major updates for several more years, potentially until iPadOS 19, with security updates extending possibly until 2027.
  • Practical Lifespan: Users seeking the longest possible software support and compatibility with the latest applications will find the iPad 2020 offers a significantly extended practical lifespan compared to the iPad 2017. The newer model's hardware is also better equipped to handle future software demands.

Release year

2017

2020

Compatible with latest Update

No

Yes

Operating system

iPadOS

iPadOS

Minimum system requirements (iPadOS)

iPadOS 16

iPadOS 18

Performance

The performance capabilities of these two iPad models are a key differentiator, primarily due to the advancements in their internal processing units.

  • Processor Capabilities: The iPad 2017 is powered by the Apple A9 chip, while the iPad 2020 features the more advanced Apple A12 Bionic chip, which also includes a Neural Engine. The A12 Bionic offers a substantial increase in processing power and efficiency.
  • Real-world Usage: For everyday tasks such as web browsing, email, and media consumption, both devices perform adequately. However, the iPad 2020 provides a noticeably smoother experience when running more demanding applications, engaging in graphically intensive games, or multitasking with multiple apps open simultaneously. The additional 1GB of RAM in the iPad 2020 (3GB vs 2GB in the iPad 2017) also contributes to better multitasking fluidity.
  • System Responsiveness: The iPad 2020 exhibits faster app loading times and a more responsive overall user interface, making it better suited for users who frequently switch between applications or rely on their tablet for productivity tasks that require more computational power.

Memory (GB)

2 GB

3 GB

Processor

Apple A9

Apple A12 Bionic

Screen quality

Both the iPad 2017 and iPad 2020 feature Apple's Retina display technology, providing clear visuals, though there are differences in size and display characteristics.

  • Display Technology: Both models utilize an IPS LCD panel, known for offering good color accuracy and wide viewing angles.
  • Resolution and Clarity: The iPad 2017 has a 9.7-inch display with a 2048x1536 pixel resolution, while the iPad 2020 features a slightly larger 10.2-inch display with a 2160x1620 pixel resolution. Both maintain a pixel density of 264 pixels per inch (ppi), ensuring sharp text and images.
  • Viewing Experience: The iPad 2017's display is not fully laminated and lacks an anti-reflective coating, which can lead to more reflections in bright environments. The iPad 2020's display, while also not fully laminated, includes an oleophobic coating to resist fingerprints and offers a slightly more expansive viewing area due to its larger size. Both offer similar peak brightness levels.

Resolution

2048 x 1536

2160 x 1620

True Tone

No

No

Promotion

No

No

Screen type

Retina display

Retina display

Pixel density

264ppp

264ppp

Brightness

500 nits brightness

500 nits brightness

Sound quality

Speakers

Stereo speakers

Stereo speakers

Audiovisual

The camera systems on the iPad 2017 and iPad 2020 are designed for functional use rather than advanced photography, with largely similar specifications.

  • Camera System Capabilities: Both iPads are equipped with an 8-megapixel rear camera and a 1.2-megapixel front-facing camera. These specifications are suitable for everyday tasks such as document scanning, casual photos, and video calls.
  • Photography Performance: In well-lit conditions, both cameras capture adequate images. Neither model is optimized for low-light photography, where image quality may degrade with increased noise and reduced detail.
  • Video Recording: Both devices support 1080p video recording at 30 frames per second with their rear cameras, and 720p video recording with their front cameras, making them suitable for basic video capture and communication.

Miscellaneous

Beyond the core components, several practical features and design elements distinguish the iPad 2017 and iPad 2020, impacting their overall utility and user experience.

  • Connectivity Options: Both models offer Wi-Fi connectivity (802.11a/b/g/n/ac, dual-band) and are available in Wi-Fi + Cellular configurations for mobile data access. Both also include Bluetooth 4.2 for connecting wireless accessories.
  • Port Types: Both iPads feature a Lightning port for charging and data transfer, and they both retain the 3.5mm headphone jack, offering compatibility with a wide range of audio accessories.
  • Accessory Support: A significant advantage of the iPad 2020 is its compatibility with the 1st generation Apple Pencil and the Smart Keyboard. This expands its functionality for note-taking, drawing, and typing, making it a more versatile tool for productivity and creative tasks. The iPad 2017 does not support these accessories.
  • Dimensions and Weight: The iPad 2017 measures 240 x 169.5 x 7.5 mm and weighs 469g (Wi-Fi model). The iPad 2020 is slightly larger and heavier at 250.6 x 174.1 x 7.5 mm and 490g (Wi-Fi model), reflecting its larger screen size. Both remain portable for daily use.

Weight

478 oz

490 oz

Width

16.95 in

17.41 in

Height

24 in

25.06 in

Depth

0.75 in

0.75 in

Screen size (in)

9.7

10.2

Network

Wi-Fi + 4G

Wi-Fi

Carrier compatibility

Unlocked

Without SIM Port

Wi-Fi version

Wi-Fi 6 802.11a/b/g/n/ac

Wi-Fi 6 802.11a/b/g/n/ac

Bluetooth version

Bluetooth 4.2

Bluetooth 4.2

Face ID

No

No

Touch ID

Yes

Yes

Connector

Lightning connector

Lightning connector

When evaluating the iPad 2017 and iPad 2020, user feedback often highlights distinct strengths and weaknesses for each model. Users of the iPad 2017 frequently praise its compact 9.7-inch form factor and its continued ability to handle basic tasks like web browsing, email, and media consumption. However, common criticisms revolve around its aging processor, which can lead to slower performance with newer, more demanding applications, and the lack of support for modern accessories like the Apple Pencil and Smart Keyboard.

The iPad 2020, on the other hand, is generally lauded for its significantly improved performance thanks to the A12 Bionic chip, offering a smoother experience for multitasking and more intensive applications. Its longer expected software support and compatibility with the 1st generation Apple Pencil and Smart Keyboard are also frequently cited as major advantages, enhancing its utility for students and professionals. Some users note that while the camera is functional, it remains largely unchanged from previous generations, and the continued use of the Lightning port rather than USB-C is sometimes mentioned.

Users prioritizing a more compact device for essential functions such as casual internet use, video streaming, and light productivity may find the iPad 2017 sufficient for their needs. Conversely, users who require more robust performance for demanding apps, desire a longer period of software updates, and value the enhanced functionality provided by Apple Pencil and Smart Keyboard support will likely find the iPad 2020 better suited to their requirements. Both models are available as quality-assured refurbished options, providing an eco-friendly alternative for those looking to make an informed and sustainable choice.

See all articles

Our recent comparisons